An interesting debate.

[Simian]

as you say an interesting read and for a tournament it could make a difference (though i think they've got the maths wrong on it) my issue with these dice is that its hard to tell if its meant to be the 6 or the 1, especially when your opponent has 5/6 different symboled dice and some are 1's some are 6's. it makes it a real pain to keep track what you're looking for especially when they're rolling lots of them and picking them up as successes.